Testimonials & Reviews
All Island Dermatology
Dermatology and Cosmetic Center located in Garden City, NY & Glen Cove, NY
All Island Dermatology always appreciates feedback from our valued patients. To date, we’re thrilled to have collected 1074 reviews with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Please read what others are saying about All Island Dermatology below, and as always, we would love to collect your feedback.
Maria Z.
Submitted 07/31/26
Dr Nicoll is very nice I like to com to the appointment
I am recommending my daughter to her
GHOTIE S.
Submitted 07/31/26
I have been sick for the last 35 years. I have More than1000 of doctors experience. But I never seen never seen in my life a doctor like this so rude without looking at what your problem is you only prescribe prednisone prednisone prednisone nothing else I accidentally saw him yesterday I made the biggest mistake and I’m not even taking his prednisone. It was just a bug bite. He’s telling me it’s eczema. He doesn’t even look at me. I am telling him my eyebrows bleeding. He doesn’t wanna even look at it. This is not a doctor. I’m sorry anyone is going to him. I think it’s a mistake. I will never see his face again. I rather have some PA looking at me with a good attitude. He was running. He just wants to see patient and go home whatever he wants to do. That’s not the way you’re supposed to be thank you thank you.
LESLIE S.
Submitted 07/30/26
Dr. Bacigalupi and his staff are kind and competent. Thank you, all!
ROBERT D.
Submitted 07/24/26
Great
MARIA C.
Submitted 07/22/26
Nichole is so attentive and professional, a wonderful doctor and I would recommend her to anyone.
Rita L R.
Submitted 07/22/26
Everyone was super kind and professional
Kathleen D.
Submitted 07/21/26
My experience with Dr Bacigalypi was very positive. He and his staff took time to explain everything and they very helpful. He was very caring during the procedure. I would highly recommend him to friends.
Arthur J S.
Submitted 07/20/26
Dr Bacigalupi and his Tesm are Terrific
ALAN S.
Submitted 07/08/26
Professional
Jeffrey B.
Submitted 07/08/26
Excellent doctor. Explains what he is doing and how to care for yourself.
Theresa W.
Submitted 06/26/26
Nicole Tuffarelli and assistants are always efficient and welcoming when I come in. Nicole Tuffarelli is a good diagnostic NP. She always gets me the right treatment first time around. I trust her. Also the front staff is very efficient and welcoming. I have been coming here over 7 years.
I would recommend this office.
DEBORAH D.
Submitted 06/23/26
Nicole is the best
She is very professional and has a great eye for any skin issues
She makes you feel very comfortable when having a full body check
I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dermatologist
EUGENE F O.
Submitted 06/23/26
Pleasant thorough and efficient… could not ask for more
LINDA F.
Submitted 06/18/26
Doctors and assistance were very cordial very experienced and the place is immaculate. It’s a pleasure to be there.
Marie T M.
Submitted 06/17/26
Doc and staff pleasant and friendly. Highly recommend them.
Daniel D.
Submitted 06/17/26
Everything was great
JOHN M S.
Submitted 06/16/26
My experience with Dr Radha Mikkilineni has always been excellent!
Dorothy G.
Submitted 06/16/26
He carefully examined the body; found no concerns. Will return next year.
JOHN C.
Submitted 06/10/26
Dr. Onorato was great. Gave me full attention and his detailed observations make me feel at ease about anything pertaining to my skin. I absolutely recommend him to anyone who needs a dermatologist.
Mildred R.
Submitted 05/30/26
Pleasant, doctor competent; explained procedure and provided me with diagnoses of skin blemishes.